Divide into small groups. Discuss and prepare a written summary of your group's responses to the following questions. Make sure every member of your group has a copy of the summary with every group member's name on it, and with the name of the recorder.

1.    Give three examples of complex question.  Explain how they work.








2.    If all questions involve presuppositions, what makes complex question fallacious?  Defend your answer.









3.      Give three examples of negative or positive presuppositions in statements.









4.    What is the difference between circumstantial and abusive ad hominem?  Give one example of each.










Michael Kagan, group work for PHL 310, February 18, 2019